Snark Infested Waters ~ Bob Edwards

Bob Edwards


Sign Up for Email Notifications

Just ask your doctor

Posted on May 5, 2017 by Bob Edwards

Hospitals in Mogadishu aren’t great and in Syria they are routinely bombed, but in America even low-education voters understand that hospitals are a public service as vital as police, fire, water and Twitter.

Fortunately, Sonoma Valley Hospital is a good one, and Measure E will provide a necessary $55 increase in the annual hospital parcel tax to help keep it healthy.

But whenever our hospital asks for help – which isn’t often – there are those who insist we don’t need to spend money on a hospital because (wait for it) there are other hospitals much farther away. “Who needs it,” they demand, “when other hospitals are an exciting 30-minute, fun-filled ambulance ride to Napa or Santa Rosa, sirens wailing and EMT’s pounding your chest!?”

They’d have us believe the $55 parcel tax increase for the hospital (15 cents a day more on the current tax bill) is Tyrannical Government run amok. But for anyone who owns taxable property in Sonoma Valley, 15 cents is chump-change. When Measure E passes, the total hospital parcel tax ($250 a year, or 68 cents a day) will still cost less than household garbage pick-up.

Of course, no tax increase is justified if it isn’t necessary, but this one is. For example, it’s well known that reimbursements the hospital receives for serving Medicare and Medicaid patients do not always cover the cost of providing those services. Yet thousands of Valley residents use those programs to pay their hospital bills.

While providing first class care, the hospital also keeps a very sharp eye on costs. Safety tip: never ever get between hospital management and a stray nickel. But when prudent cost cutting still isn’t enough, a smart community covers the shortfall.

It certainly does if it values Emergency Room service, and our Valley does. SVH sees around 10,000 emergency patients a year and ranks in the top 25 percent of hospitals nationwide for patient satisfaction.  But ER capability is a big expense and SVH’s ER is no exception. The law requires ER’s to be attached to a hospital with surgical and other capabilities. A stand-alone Urgent Care Center – a ‘doc-in-a-box’ — is not an ER or a hospital.

The law also requires ER’s to treat everyone, regardless of ability to pay. Depending on one’s politics, that’s either Socialism (!) or compassion at its finest. Either way, when a Lego wedges in little Tommy’s windpipe or Granny breaks a hip, the ER is there 24/7/365. “Yes on E” will help support the hospital, its ER and its many healthcare services described at

Obviously, good healthcare also requires doctors and the hospital is a big reason the Valley has a lot more doctors than, say, Pisgah, Alabama. Doctors like having a hospital nearby so they can send and tend their patients there and have access to lab tests, imaging, skilled nursing help and other complexities vital to a 21st century medical practice.

Those who think they’d be financially ahead if Measure E fails should consider how far and fast the market value of their property could drop if the Valley is suddenly many miles from quality medical care instead of mere minutes.

Finally, if an extra $55/yr. seems a lot, consider that the hospital with its ER also provides hundreds of the best-paying jobs in the Valley. Local spending by the hospital, its suppliers and its many employees support countless other jobs in other local businesses.

Ask your doctor if Measure E isn’t right for you, and the whole family.

3 thoughts on “Just ask your doctor

  1. A few years ago, a 15-year-old girl was admitted to SVH to have a routine tonsillectomy. I hope you recall this as it was published in our local newspaper. How do you think she would vote on measure E? Well, since she bled to death while admitted, she cannot vote. You folks in the video, who say you would rather move away than not have a hospital, or “just shoot me” if you must go out of the valley to a Trauma Certified Hospital are cruel. Remember, those who did not make it when treated at SVH won’t have a vote and your video is not funny or helpful. Based on fear it is. Why do you think those who suffer major injuries due to a vehicle crash on our local highways are sent elsewhere? Or struck by a car while using a cross walk in town, are sent elsewhere? Why does SVH ask for $3.8 million a year to cover a $1 million shortfall? Really want a responsible hospital? Then vote NO on measure E and make them come back in September with a reasonable request for a $100-dollar parcel tax. Maybe it’s time to move on to some new board members.

    1. Girl dies from a tonsilectomy?? More fake news. Every hospital has had people who die while there, and for reasons that vary all over the lot — from gross neglect to ‘they were dying when they came in the door.’ To say that the hospital doesn’t warrant saving because someone once died there is like closing a restaurant because its full of hungry people. Idiot.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>