Join us on Facebook
What's Happening
Media-savvy SV grads receive Film Fest scholarships
The Sun needs your help to survive
Columnist, Blogs & Reports
more >>
Fred Allebach
Connecting the Dots
Fred Allebach

Food as a core equity issue

When I first got to Sonoma in 2006, I volunteered at La Luz for the Catholic Charities-Redwood Empire Food Bank food giveaway on Fridays. At first, I was in line getting food myself, as I had no work. After a few times, I met Mario Castillo and he said, why don’t you volunteer? I did, for about a year. First I was the parking and traffic guy, then I moved to the food line. You wouldn’t think that such an operation had tensions, but La Luz staff were continually having to smooth over issues among the volunteers as to who would or wouldn’t do what. Everybody wanted the gravy and gratitude of handing the food out; few wanted to hump boxes around and do the dirty work. Eventually, I started getting paid work and moved on from free food. A number of years later in 2016, as I learned more about sustainability, I became very interested in the county food system. This started as a combination of having been on food lines, being aware of high food prices in Sonoma, and being concerned with equity. I attempted to leverage my status as a commissioner on the city’s Community Services and Environment Commission (CSEC), along with Chris Petlock, to lower the Tuesday Farmers Market managers’ fees in exchange for them adding Food Stamps benefits for the public. We did this because it aligned with a 2014 city council resolution to support the county’s Food Action Plan, which has four pillars, one of which is social equity, and dignified access to affordable, healthy food.   The CSEC reduced fee in exchange for social good was shot down by an appeal by council member Gary Edwards with the appeal upheld by a 4 to 1 council vote (Edwards, Hundley, Harrington, Agrimonti, with David Cook dissenting). In the end, the CSEC’s core food justice motive, and alignment with city council goals, became obscured by a lot of tangential issues concerning the market in general.  As far as I can see things have not changed much in Sonoma Valley in terms of equitable access to affordable healthy food. Price is still the critical threshold for poor people, and prices have not come down. Wages have not gone up nearly enough. Now, the C-19 crisis has laid bare existing social equity issues in the Valley. Essential workers earn crumbs for wages, live paycheck to paycheck, and have no cushion to shelter in place. Back to work and re-opening turns out to be a class-based possible death sentence. In all of this, food remains the most basic need. In this crisis, the Valley’s Food Task Force has worked hard and with goodwill, but government and non-profits remain disconnected from disadvantaged communities at a fundamental level. Why? No POC (people of color) are in positions of power. Advocacy and confronting equity issues head-on is avoided. It’s all white people and white charity money running the show. A dependent, paternalistic relationship is showcased.  Since C-19, as a white person, I’ve had to struggle with this same tension, of being really sympathetic and in solidarity, yet still having a good deal of privilege. I still operate under assumptions and a worldview that makes for a gulf in perceptions, and benefits. Class and race burdens are not hitting me. How to address this disconnect? Basically, I need to move over and let POC speak for themselves, and do whatever I can to make POC agency the priority. This is not about my voice, feelings, or sensibilities. In human relations, if you want to empower somebody, give up pretensions to control, get out of the way, and allow others to have their own voice and agency. And when in history has any ruling class ever given up power and control just like that? About never. This is a messy power shift that is not easy. In fact, power may have to be demanded and taken, not given, even in this C-19 critical transformation moment. One big equity issue is city-Springs municipal fragmentation. Unfair representational issues are evident here, as they were to me as a newbie in 2006. Too much power and resources in Sonoma, not enough in the Springs. Recent city-county cooperation has been a good sign. However, for the end game, we need one government here, with district elections, not two captains for the same ship. It’s not right to have classes and races segregated like they are here. The power differential is just not right. As for food, prices are still unreasonably high and prevent equitable access to healthy food. Prices are rising on meat and dairy as we speak. With the Food Task Force the city has finally shown support for the 2014 Resolution, to support the Food Action Plan -- but as charity, not as a proactive move to support the equity pillar of the FAP. Food is still a major piece of a larger inequity puzzle in the Valley. Enter Food For All. FFA is asserting grassroots agency for the under-represented. It’s a small but critical step in the direction of Springs Latino/ POC self-determination. The status quo is still too content, and all too adept at finding all the reasons why not to share political power. If we are at a critical transition point, and status quo actors won’t really change, what’s left for the underrepresented is to seize power in whatever ways they can. Hopefully, FFA will be the beginning of real district representation, just like I talked with Mario about the food line 14 years ago.    
Continue Story...
Another tax on Sonoma cannabis? Another tax on Sonoma cannabis?

My understanding is that the City of Sonoma is planning to place a 4% Cannabis Tax initiative on the... Continue

Sonoma Plaza protest: ‘Passionate but peaceful’ Sonoma Plaza protest: 'Passionate but peaceful'

A crowd of more than 300 gathered on Sonoma Plaza this afternoon to peacefully protest the murder of... Continue

• Editorial: Boarded windows send the wrong message
• City officials expect peaceful protest Wednesday on Sonoma Plaza
• Community Center moves the arts online
• Feuding Supervisors, Sheriff issue a joint statement. But what does it really say?
• Update from Sonoma Overnight Support — ‘On the move again’
• Sonoma Police will continue to enforce C-19 health orders
• Watchdog groups want County review of Amazon’s Sonoma warehouse deal
• Sonoma County Sheriff will ignore public health rules, officials somewhat miffed
• Addressing the needs of the Valley’s most vulnerable
• Meeting the challenge of Food for All
Letters & Opinion
more >>
SUN Columnist & Blogs
more >>
Public Citizen - Larry Barnett
Before It's Too Late - Eric Gullotta
Progressive Majority Coalition - Ben Boyce
Snark Infested Waters - Bob Edwards
Board Walk - Susan Gorin
Nonprofit Matters - Dr. B.J. Bischoff
What's Up With That? - Katy Byrne
Connecting the Dots - Fred Allebach
Voices of the New Majority - Mario Castillo
Creative Arts - Deb Carlen, Editor
Sun In-Depth Report - Kelsey Maddox
Under the Sun: Interviews -
Rude Awakenings - Catherine Sevenau
Taxpertise - Bonnie Lee
Conversations on Aging - Kelsey Maddox
Keep An Open Mind - Dan de la Torre
@SuperSonoma - Socorro Shiels
Know Pain, Know Gain - Jay Rooke
Find What You're looking For


Covid-19 News
County eases access to trails, beaches

A walk in the park will become, well, more of a walk in the park as restrictions on outdoor Sonoma County recreation ease on Wednesday, June 3. Sonoma County’s health officer on Tuesday further eased restrictions on outdoor recreation during the Covid-19 pandemic by issuing an order that allows park agencies to reopen coastal parking... Continue

What We're Following
Stories of interest from around the Web
50 richest philanthropists are cheap skates during Covid-19
> Washington Post - June 4th, 2020
In praise of Mac and Cheese
> The Conversation - June 3rd, 2020
The state of our Union: suddenly, George W. Bush is the voice of reason
> Politco - June 3rd, 2020
The state budget is going in the tank. Is legal sports betting inevitable?
> State Senator Bill Dodd - June 2nd, 2020
Santa Rosa PD suspends use of Nixle app
> City of Santa Rosa - June 2nd, 2020
Could this be the beginning of a new food economy?
> Yes - June 1st, 2020
Before you come into our business, you must promise not to sue
> Reuters - June 1st, 2020
Insights from someone who harvests what you eat
> The Guardian - May 31st, 2020
Looping, grouping and digital: survey shows what teachers want when school resumes
> Education Week - May 31st, 2020
Amazon develops ‘robotic consumer’ to order robot-delivered items
> Journal of Unintended Consequences - May 30th, 2020
50 SF restaurants on what they’ll need to stay in business
> - May 29th, 2020
The ‘virtual cat show‘ is now a thing
> Catster Magazine - May 29th, 2020
Monitoring sewer water could potentially pinpoint likely Covid hotspots
> Science News - May 28th, 2020
That $350 ‘anti-5G BioShied’ USB stick? It’s a scam
> The Verge - May 28th, 2020
Evolution-wise, does the threat of pandemic lead to more female infidelity?
> Psychology Today - May 27th, 2020
Quick quiz: Is this the end of the SAT? 
> Washington Post - May 25th, 2020
Joining the ranks of social media influencers: gardeners
> Modern Farmer - May 25th, 2020
Check in on the babies via the National Zoo’s Cheetah Cub Cam
> Smithsonian - May 24th, 2020
The state of reality TV: new show has 15 men competing to impregnate 41-year-old woman
> The Mirror - May 23rd, 2020
Hand sanitizer left in hot Texas car bursts into flames
> - May 22nd, 2020
More Following Stories...
Link to Live Crime Map
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!