Join us on Facebook
What's Happening
Events & Entertainment
Ready or not… Here come the holidays
Columnist, Blogs & Reports
more >>
Larry Barnett
Public Citizen
Larry Barnett

The Pseudo-Science of CEQA and an EIR

An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) responds to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), legislation intended to asses and address the environmental impacts of large developments, such as air-quality, construction debris and dust, noise and other factors. It takes only a few minutes reviewing the EIR of a large commercial development to realize that its use of quasi-scientific methods produces a dehumanized document all but inaccessible to the general public.

Large development requires major financial commitment, and all real estate investment is predicated upon projected forecasts of profits and return-on-investment. Such forecasts attempt to use reasonable assumptions about income and expenses; the larger the project and length of forecast, the greater the risk such assumptions are inaccurate. An accurate assessment of risk is vital to successfully predicting outcomes, but forecasting the future is always speculative.

The purpose of CEQA and an EIR it requires is essentially the same: determining the likely outcomes and environmental effects of a large project while attempting to reduce the risk of harm to the environment - the health of people, contamination of land and water, and effects on transportation.

Forecasting the future requires establishing baseline measurements of current conditions and attempting to determine how proposed projects will affect those measurements. In other words, an attempt to employ a "scientific" method to assess probabilities is what the EIR process entails. Accordingly, an EIR is a data-driven document, since only by reducing environmental factors to quantifiable, calculable numbers is it possible to predict probabilities. The difficulty, however, is that human beings and non-quantifiable factors such as quality-of-life, sense-of-place and community character cannot be reduced to calculable units. This is why an EIR becomes a dehumanized process.

The preparation of an EIR is the work of specialists. These specialists have expertise in the environmental regulations that must be satisfied and ways to satisfy them. Their method, after identifying potential impacts, is to decide if the project impacts are significant or less-than-significant. If they are deemed significant (as determined by calculations and forecasts) then they must be mitigated, and the EIR includes such mitigations. The work of EIR specialists is essentially opaque to anyone not a specialist, and challenging an EIR requires comparable specialist expertise. The appendix alone of a current project before the Planning Commission is 413 pages long. When reduced to pages of "objective" data, the "subjective" human element is unfortunately left far behind.

Thus the evaluation of auto traffic, for example, becomes a matter of objective measurement - traffic counts and trip generation pertaining to "test periods" or comparisons with comparable projects. Yet, traffic studies are not the same as the experience of living in a community day-to-day and gaining a "feel" for how things are or how they change over time. "Feelings" are not scientifically quantifiable or calculable, even though they are at the heart of human experience. Thus they find no place in CEQA or an EIR.

CEQA and an EIR have value, but are simply one element in determining if a proposed large project is right for a community. Applying a "scientific" methodology to human culture is tempting and seductive, but far from definitive. Therefore, it's worth remembering that both CEQA and an EIR are specifically intended to protect the environment for living things - like people - and their safety, health and welfare.

Continue Story...
Local Movie Trailers and Videos of Interest - more >>
SUN Columnist & Blogs
more >>
Public Citizen - Larry Barnett
The Sun Eats - Sonoma Valley Sun
Before It's Too Late - Eric Gullotta
The Sonoma Garden - Karen Boness
Progressive Majority Coalition - Ben Boyce
Taxpertise - Bonnie Lee
Snark Infested Waters - Bob Edwards
Springs Eternal - Gina Cuclis
Board Walk - Susan Gorin
Nonprofit Matters - Dr. B.J. Bischoff
What's Up With That? - Katy Byrne
Connecting the Dots - Fred Allebach
This Week in Politics - Ron Willis Ed.D.
Voices of the New Majority - Loretta Carpio Carr
Creative Arts - Deb Carlen, Editor
Sun In-Depth Report - Sonoma Valley Sun
Under the Sun: Interviews - Sonoma Valley Sun
Call the Super - Louann Carlomagno
Emily’s Post - Emily
Rude Awakenings - Catherine Sevenau
Find What You're looking For


What We're Following
Stories of interest from around the Web
Traffic near Napa is forecast to only get worse in the future
> Napa Valley Register
Abalone divers are objecting to new rules and new catch limits
> Marin IJ
UC promises to protect its undocumented students
Are you a crime victim? California has a new system to keep you in the loop about offenders
> Sacramento Bee
Most of the Sonoma Coast has now been opened to crab fishing
> Santa Rosa Press Democrat
Teachers are in short supply in California, and it’s not getting any better
> Los Angeles Times
Just built micro-units coming up for rent in Oakland. Can you guess how big and how much ?
Now that pot has been legalized, will you find it right next door?
> Kenwood Press
Dogs like mushrooms, but many are poisonous; take caution
> San Francisco Chronicle
A new property owner will try to navigate the creation of affordable housing in Napa
> Napa Valley Register
The median price of a home in Marin County has jumped to $1.1 million
> Marin IJ
California’s population of seniors will increase dramatically in the next decades, as will the number which are disabled
Gov. Brown has selected Xavier Bacerra, son of immigrants, as the state’s Attorney General
> Sacramento Bee
$15/hr. minimum wage demand protests are spreading through California cities
> New York Times
The Syar Quarry in Napa County is facing a slew of lawsuits
> Napa Valley Register
Marin County joins Sonoma County in being recognized for the terrible condition of its roads
> Marin IJ
Hear about the new plan to alter river water extraction to save the dying Delta?
New rules being drafted to protect schools from pesticide spray worry farmers
> Sacramento Bee
Pot trimmer “immigrants” cause tensions in North Coast county towns
> Santa Rosa Press Democrat
European satellite study since 2015 shows sinking in San Rafael Bay and new shifts along Hayward fault
> New York Times
More Following Stories...
Live Traffic
Link to Live Crime Map