Join us on Facebook
What's Happening
more>>
Though plans for a cannabis dispensary in the back of the building are on hold, Jon Early proceeds with the remodel of 865-875 West Napa Street, the former sites of the Wine Annex and the Community Café. All city approvals are in hand, he says, and discussion with new restaurant tenants are underway for reopening as soon as this summer.
Pipe dreams: Will Sonoma miss out on the marijuana boom?
Food & Wine
more >>
c2510ffaa69a3e71_DSCF2712
One of the world’s best wines is sold by…Walmart
Columnist, Blogs & Reports
more >>
Fred Allebach
Connecting the Dots
Fred Allebach

Boyes Springs Food Market project review

At the recent Springs Community Alliance meeting, Tim Sloat, of KSMattson Partners LP, made a presentation of the Boyes Springs Food Market project. The owners of the property are Ken and Stacy Mattson, who also own Sonoma’s Best, the Moon Mountain property, and according to an internet search, also numerous properties in Sacramento, Fairfield, Piedmont, Vacaville, and a real state/ property management company in Sacramento. KS Mattson is also in the process of developing the old Springs Lanning property in a project called Noodle Springs, this in collaboration with Sondra Bernstein of Girl and the Fig. And, they are currently building  another project in Lovall Valley Rd. Impressions of Boyes Springs Food Center project I was favorably impressed by the architecture, drawings and plans for the Boyes Springs Food Center property. I like the integration of styles, the inclusion of modern sensibilities, the roof decks and other creative, cutting edge ideas like elevator parking. My overall sense is that KS Mattson is an innovative group who want to be good community actors. Tim Sloat said in the presentation that the Mattsons are “invested in a community sense, long term.” The Mattsons are going beyond the call of duty by being sensitive to current tenants on the property, offering transition housing, and offering them first crack at affordable units to be developed, and also offering to negotiate rent prices down if need be. When I compare this approach to other developers, who grudgingly present the minimum affordable unit quota and nothing more, I get the sense of the type of developer I have been hoping for: one who, after they already have it made, can offer something back and don’t just need more, more, more money. Breaking even or even taking a bit of a haircut is something that the very wealthy can do for the community. And why not? Some of the biggest money actors have pledged to give it all away. In general, the Mattsons have an upside and social consciousness to them that only one other high-wealth developer in town seems to have. More of this style and approach would be great from the local developer class. Is it reasonable to expect KS Mattson to fix all the regional issues of housing affordability and gentrification in one project? No. Is it reasonable to think a developer of social conscience and good will could set the bar higher and tip other developers in a better direction? Yes. Mixed use, planned development The project is mixed use, having a commercial component, with a market, restaurant and storefronts (dwellings above) in front of the main residential area in the back. They are applying for a Planned Development, which means they are asking for variances, likely due to lot size and shape, and if the deal is accepted, for the variances and exceptions, the Mattsons will be obligated to give some positive features back to the community. A market is proposed, “a version of Sonoma’s Best” sans wine tasting, tentatively called “Boyes Best.” Something with “a different vibe” than the Boyes Food Center.  Mr. Sloat was then quick to say “but not gentrification.” One member of the public commented that a real market would be good here, given that the Springs is a known food desert. Tom Martin said, “we need a real market.” The Zen of not gentrifying gentrification? This is where the goals of fixing up an old Springs property start to collide with an inevitable increase in values and rents that will have the effect of gentrifying even if that is anticipated and tried to be mitigated. The current mix has a level of ethnic and cultural integration, a demographic, which the Mattsons see and value, but which may inevitably be undone by the introduction of a Sonoma’s Best, high-end type vibe. Only by really sticking to a plan to preserve the ethnic diversity in the Springs, can the effects of inevitable gentrification be substantially addressed. What gives the Springs its current character is exactly what will be lost in a new modern development. This then starts to get wound up in real processes of urban evolution, and notions of “progress.” One person’s blight is another’s character, and in a diverse community, all the collective hopes and dreams go into the mix, and those with the wherewithal and money drive the change. Many folks in the Springs want a type of Sonoma’s Best vibe, more cosmopolitan, an upscale, local, street-front alternative to the Sonoma Plaza area. This cohort does not want high density affordable housing everywhere, they want an upscale hang out in walking distance from their home. Fair enough. Affordable housing Mr. Sloat mentioned that the county requirement for affordable housing units for this project, was only two! For this whole project of 37 residential units. Affordable means that those who make a range around the area median income, or AMI, can afford the rents at 30% of their annual income. Sloat went on to say that KS Mattson was going to offer eight units, or 21% of the residential units as affordable, and that this was a generous offer. This may be the case when compared to the county rules for a mixed use project/ planned development. Compared to Sonoma however, a 20% inclusionary requirement is the minimum. This means KS Mattson is possibly playing the numbers a little here, in that 20% is already normal, not generous, and in order to be truly generous, an affordable inclusion would be more like 25% or 30%. 50% inclusion with 100% electric/solar ready A 2018 Sonoma County Just and Resilient Recovery Platform, made by a coalition of North Bay Jobs With Justice, Transition Sonoma Valley, 350 Bay Area, and Sonoma County Conservation Action is asking for a 50% inclusion of affordable units in new residential developments. Not only does the county need housing stock in general, the housing affordability crisis calls for more than old levels of affordable unit inclusion. The above coalition is also calling for new building to be 100% electric and solar ready. Mattsons are doing more than average To the Mattson’s credit, they are focusing on very low, low, and moderate income tenants for the affordable inclusion, and not trying to pass by only 120% AMI as “affordable.” I would suggest that county planning and zoning actors leverage some more affordable units here, in exchange for the Planned Development variance. For example, eight below AMI affordable as proposed and eight more at 120%, 140% and 160% AMI. Furthermore, Mr. Sloat’s presentation did not go into detail on the square footage of the affordable residential units. In other similar projects, the affordable units all get the worst, noisiest locations, at very low square footage, like 800 square feet per unit. It would be good to see just exactly what the location and size of the affordable units will be here in the Boyes Springs Food Center project. Perhaps Mr. Sloat can provide the public with links to the county planning documents online? Parking red flag Finally, the persistent bugaboo, parking. From the experience of how KS Mattson has managed their parking at Sonoma’s Best, which can be said to be an unregulated free-for-all with serious unaddressed public safety risks, I would say that the Mattson track record in town so far has been to push the edge of acceptable parking boundaries, and to take as much extra, on-street parking as possible. With no apparent county traffic rules or enforcement, and the county seeming to not care a whit, KS Mattson has filled the vacuum by taking over a whole rural intersection like Israeli settlement facts on the ground. This parking strategy does not bode well for the Springs where a lot of parking volume has been eliminated from the Highway 12. Look for “Boyes Best” to really mess up traffic and parking in the Springs at daily coffee times. Why go head to head with the Roasting Dog, that already has a nice coffee scene? That will only take away business from a long term valley enterprise. Conclusion In my opinion, the architecture and design is very good. The Mattsons are good actors modeling to other developers how to be better, compassionate citizens in a time of great affordable housing need. The good citizen example could be more, to bring it past what is the minimum required in Sonoma. it is likely the Mattsons can afford to do more; why not?  Parking is a red flag already at Sonoma’s Best, so buyer beware in the Springs. Anyone with feedback on the Boyes Springs food Center project can write Tim Sloat at [email protected]          
Continue Story...
School Superintendent explains student’s scary joke School Superintendent explains student's scary joke

A letter from Charles Young, Sonoma Valley Unified School District Interim Superintendent Dear Sonoma... Continue

THE WINNERS! THE WINNERS!

The results are in! The people have spoken. Eat, drink and shop local with this year’s winners.  1. Best... Continue


• Dunkin’ at the Food Bank
• Learning the ropes
• The art of healing
• Urban wine zone
• Where in Sonoma?
• Honoring the legacy
• Free help with college entrance test
• A retro look for proposed Springs project
• Sub-zero temperatures expected late Monday night
• Fire debris removal effort shifts to property owners
Letters & Opinion
more >>
VIDEO
Local Movie Trailers and Videos of Interest - more >>
SUN Columnist & Blogs
more >>
Public Citizen - Larry Barnett
Before It's Too Late - Eric Gullotta
The Sonoma Garden - Karen Boness
Progressive Majority Coalition - Ben Boyce
Snark Infested Waters - Bob Edwards
Board Walk - Susan Gorin
Nonprofit Matters - Dr. B.J. Bischoff
What's Up With That? - Katy Byrne
Connecting the Dots - Fred Allebach
Voices of the New Majority - Loretta Carpio Carr
Creative Arts - Deb Carlen, Editor
Sun In-Depth Report - Sonoma Valley Sun
Under the Sun: Interviews -
Rude Awakenings - Catherine Sevenau
Taxpertise - Bonnie Lee
The Green Tara - Serialized Novel - Sonoma Valley Sun
Reality Check - Logan Harvey
Find What You're looking For

Archives

Events & Entertainment
more>>
Peter and the Starcatcher-5
Catch a rising star
THE SUN EMAIL UPDATE
Sign up for our free daily email with the latest news, events and opinion.
What We're Following
more>>
Stories of interest from around the Web
Violence, rock-throwing and arrests in Stockton… at campus anti-gun rally
> KCRA - February 23rd, 2018
Focus on Dreamers breeds resentment from other immigrants here illegally 
> L.A. Times - February 23rd, 2018
Glitzy Manhattan socialite wanted in Russia for embezlling $200 million
> New York Post - February 23rd, 2018
Too much like college? Cal Fire academy boots nine recruits for boozing 
> Sacramento Bee - February 22nd, 2018
Singapore expanding the only place there’s room — underground 
> Smithsonian Magazine - February 22nd, 2018
The state law that would ban tackle football before high school 
> Sacramento Bee - February 19th, 2018
Encintas City Council declines to endorse campaign to make ferrets legal in California 
> San Diego Union Tribune - February 18th, 2018
Is wine industry’s 20-year growth period slowing because of cheapskate millennials?
> Wine Industry Advisor - February 15th, 2018
The battle over a housing development on a woody Napa hillside
> Napa Register - February 15th, 2018
The top 50 love songs of all time
> Billboard - February 14th, 2018
Quiz: Can you guess the romantic movie?
> Metro - February 14th, 2018
Inmate in jail’s protective custody unit attacked, stabbed 
> Sonoma County Sheriff's Office - February 14th, 2018
Why some people turn into obnoxious a-holes when drinking alcohol
> The Drinks Business - February 13th, 2018
Is California facing a ‘millionaire exodus’?
> Sacramento Bee - February 13th, 2018
Student blames airline after she flushes ‘emotional support’ hamster down toilet at airport
> Slate - February 12th, 2018
Residents pack Marin fire prevention forum
> Marin Independent Journal - February 12th, 2018
The negative voices in your teenager’s head
> Psychology Today - February 12th, 2018
Of California’s 223,000 DACA recpients, 5,000 are teachers
> Capital & Main - February 11th, 2018
The giant invasive rodent threatening Delta levees and wetlands
> KCRA - February 11th, 2018
How ‘Eat Less Meat’ ignores the role of animals in the ecosystem
> Civil Eats - February 10th, 2018
More Following Stories...
Live Traffic
Link to Live Crime Map