Join us on Facebook
What's Happening
Under the weathered
Food & Wine
more >>
Crab in the Cave
Columnist, Blogs & Reports
more >>
Larry Barnett
Public Citizen
Larry Barnett

Sonoma’s choice: community or cash cow

Sonoma Valley's close proximity to eight-million people is a physical reality. That our valley happens to be exceptionally beautiful, contains historic and charming villages, and offers some of the finest agricultural land and growing conditions in the world is also true. Yet, combine these factors with the spectacular wealth of the one-percent, and it makes our community highly vulnerable to exploitation. We face a choice: will we remain a community or be sacrificed as a cash cow?

It's our choice because as a democratic community we're able to choose our elected leaders and with them, craft our own rules. The Valley and small towns we enjoy today are not simply the happenstance of chance, but of rules and planning. From Mariano Vallejo on down, we enjoy the legacy of leaders in our community who looked ahead to the future, but also appreciated the lessons of the past. It's true that bad decisions have sometimes been made, yet experiencing the bad effects of poor decisions is often how we've learned to do things right.

During one term as Mayor of Sonoma in 2005, I had the welcome opportunity to visit Sonoma's sister city in Tuscany, Greve in Chianti. Greve, like Sonoma, is a charming old village, in fact far older than Sonoma; Medieval buildings border its town plaza, including a church originally built 1,000 years ago. The surrounding countryside is filled with vineyards and wineries, some of which have been in families for many hundreds of years. Scattered among hills planted with grapes and olive groves are homes and winery buildings built of local stone with terra cotta barrel-tile roofs; they blend into the Tuscan landscape seamlessly.

The Mayor of Greve at that time, Paolo Saturnini cordially invited me and my wife to dinner with a small group. I speak no Italian, and he no English, but his assistant was fluent in both and acted as translator. Between altogether too many courses of good food, I asked Paolo, "What has prevented the building of inappropriately large or different looking structures?" His assistant translated, but he looked at me quizzically, and then spoke. "He does not understand your question," replied his assistant. I asked it again, more simply, "Why hasn't someone built a winery that does not use stone and terra cotta barrel tiles?" He again looked puzzled and responded. "He asks, 'Why'," said his assistant, "'would anyone do that?'" Violating his community's "sense of place" was simply unthinkable to him, and his response highlighted the difference between ambition and greed.

America, however, is not Italy and Sonoma is not Greve; here wealth and individual initiative frequently overwhelm history and culture. For this reason local planning is vitally important and why we must depend upon policies and regulations that insure our "sense of place" is not violated, rules that seem unnecessary in Greve.

The choices our community makes are more important than ever. Once a physical transformation takes place, its imprint lasts for many generations. If such changes reflect the nature of who we are and what our local culture historically has been - local, small-scale, modest, respectful of past values, generous and not ego-driven - our community will thrive and living here will remain exceptional.

If, however, we succumb to the greed of profit-over-people and allow our valley to be treated as a mere cash-cow, community will be lost.

Continue Story...
Why it’s so difficult to become a U.S. citizen Why it’s so difficult to become a U.S. citizen

Sun Special Report by Anna Pier — In immigration forums offered around the Valley since election... Continue

Sonoma Planning Commission loses two members Sonoma Planning Commission loses two members

The Sonoma Planning Commission suddenly and unexpectedly lost two of its members this week after Chip... Continue

• Cover story: The Sonoma International Film Festival
• Cell tower strong-arming, Oakmont political fracas, and more
• First St. East hotel/housing project gets review
• All winners great and small
• City of Sonoma studies imposing housing impact fees
• Sheriff’s update: missing Temelec woman found
• Have you been drunk since St. Patricks Day?
• Three tactics to end bullying
• Missing at-risk man found
• A water plan to benefit both fish and people
Letters & Opinion
more >>
Local Movie Trailers and Videos of Interest - more >>
SUN Columnist & Blogs
more >>
Public Citizen - Larry Barnett
The Sun Eats - Sonoma Valley Sun
Before It's Too Late - Eric Gullotta
The Sonoma Garden - Karen Boness
Progressive Majority Coalition - Ben Boyce
Taxpertise - Bonnie Lee
Snark Infested Waters - Bob Edwards
Springs Eternal - Gina Cuclis
Board Walk - Susan Gorin
Nonprofit Matters - Dr. B.J. Bischoff
What's Up With That? - Katy Byrne
Connecting the Dots - Fred Allebach
This Week in Politics - Ron Willis Ed.D.
Voices of the New Majority - Alejandro Águilar
Creative Arts - Deb Carlen, Editor
Sun In-Depth Report - Sonoma Valley Sun
Under the Sun: Interviews - Sonoma Valley Sun
Call the Super - Louann Carlomagno
Emily’s Post - Emily
Rude Awakenings - Catherine Sevenau
Find What You're looking For


Events & Entertainment
Final week of SV Museum of Art show
Readers Survey
What We're Following
Stories of interest from around the Web
Today’s wind and rain will be followed by another round this weekend
> San Francisco Chronicle
Cannabis is fueling a rush of land purchases in Sonoma County
> North Bay Business Journal
Rodenticides come under attack in Marin by wildlife experts
> Marin IJ
California’s Chief Justice disses Trump for dissing judges
Planning to take your laptop with you when you travel? The rules are changing…again
> New York Times
The population of Napa County has grown by less than 1% in the past year
> Napa Valley Register
Rep. Mike Thompson’s reacts to Republicans abandoning repeal of Affordable Care Act
> Rep. Mike Thompson
Trumpcare is DOA — Obamacare remains the law of the land
> Sacramento Bee
The Oroville Dam spillway still poses a “very significant risk”
The roomate from hell? A student at SRJC has been arrested for attempted murder of his roomates
> Santa Rosa Press Democrat
Here’s sobering news: rates of lead poisoning in children in many California communities are higher than in Flint, MI
> Reuters
Governor Brown certainly has stirred things up in Washington D.C. this week
> Associated Press
The Sierra snowpack has an astonishing amount of snow
> New York Times
Want your friends to track your movements? Google mapping makes it so
> San Francisco Chronicle
The answer to no-shows at pricey restaurants? Prepaid reservations
> North Bay Business Journal
Marin County is hoping to discourage pesticide use among its residents
> Marin IJ
Trump is a threat to California’s coast, according to the newest Coastal Comm. member
A Stanford climatologist says California’s drought/flood oscillation will get even worse
> New York Times
Trip to Mars survives NASA buget cuts
> USA Today
Farmworker housing in Napa may get a boost from two bills being considered
> Napa Valley Register
More Following Stories...
Live Traffic
Link to Live Crime Map