Join us on Facebook
What's Happening
Events & Entertainment
Transcendence Theatre opens June 9
Columnist & Blogs
more >>
Larry Barnett
Public Citizen
Larry Barnett

Death as a selling point

I've always wondered if it's a matter of translation; namely did the the tablets brought down Mt. Sinai by Moses prohibit killing or murder? From what I can tell, most people think "Thou shalt not kill" fully covers the topic, generating reams of argument about - what else? - the Death Penalty. Whatever the translation problem, however, it's evident that death at the hands of another is a long-standing human problem, big enough to make the commandment list  alongside coveting, which appears to be an even bigger problem since it filled three slots out-of-ten. The difference between killing and murder is not simply a matter of nuance. Semantically, all murder is killing, but apparently not all killing is murder. The distinction appears as a matter of agency, which is to say killing is not murder if it is sanctioned by the state. It is this distinction which guides the conduct of most modern armies, law enforcement, and prison guards; in defending peace one who kills others is regarded as noble, and is placed in a position of honor. Accordingly, to be killed in the act of defending others, while following orders or as a matter of principle is called "the ultimate sacrifice" and we solemnly lower our heads in recognition at sacred ceremonies. Death at the hands of another may indeed be a "sacrifice" in some cases, but it's sometimes purely a matter of perspective. Did Eric Garner make the ultimate sacrifice for a matter of principle when he died on a Staten Island sidewalk while suffering a policeman's choke-hold for selling loose cigarettes? Did the punishment fit the crime or should his name be honored in the Tobacco Hall of Fame as a fallen defender? Armed forces recruiters never explicitly say "join us and get permission to kill" but it's an underlying sales pitch. Same could be said for police work and guarding prisoners; the job confers authority to exercise lethal power backed by the agency of The State. The controversy arises when circumstances indicate that "force" - as it's euphemistically called - is used inappropriately and without just cause. When and if this happens, "killing" becomes "murder." The dividing line's not exactly clear, which with coveting is why courtroom's were invented. The Islamic State, for example, is against killing, except when it's done in the name of The State; it should be noted, however, that slavery and amputations are ok. What we might conventionally call murder ISIS calls killing, and the idea is so attractive to some that homicidal recruits from all over the world are flocking to ISIS to get in on a piece of the action. Cloaked in fundamentalist interpretations harkening back to medieval times, ISIS takes the words of the Koran strictly literal and the implication of a reestablished Caliphate seriously. Like any strictly literal fundamentalism, to many of us this sounds crazy, but then much of our Bible sounds crazy if taken literally. Non-violence has also been used as a selling point, but regrettably, with far less recruiting success. It's one thing to die at the hands of another, but for most giving up the opportunity to kill in return lacks a certain element of reciprocal symmetry. So it appears we're stuck with our tragic and uncomfortable situation, fearing death while embracing it at the same time. Good for gun sales, bad for bodies.
Continue Story...
Local Movie Trailers and Videos of Interest - more >>
SUN Columnist & Blogs
more >>
Public Citizen - Larry Barnett
The Sun Eats - Sarah Stierch
The Wine Guy - Greg Walter
Turning Stones - George McKale
Pets - Vallard C. Forsythe, DVM
Before It's Too Late - Eric Gullotta
Progressive Majority Coalition - Ben Boyce
Taxpertise - Bonnie Lee
Growers Notebook - David Cook
Snark Infested Waters - Bob Edwards
Springs Eternal - Gina Cuclis
Board Walk - Susan Gorin
Nonprofit Matters - Dr. B.J. Bischoff
Body Talk - Heather Morgan
What's Up With That? - Katy Byrne
Find What You're looking For


What We're Following
Stories of interest from around the Web
Coalition looks at Napa and Wine Country future; Vision 2050
> Napa Valley Register
Sonoma Mayor Cook proposes increased use of desalination, but experience indicates it’s no panacea
Sonoma Valley Museum of Art features artists’ re-purposing of used wine barrels
> Wine Business
Floating solar panels now an option for Ag and winery energy production
> North Bay Business Journal
City Council begins to establish goals for 2015 at special session
> Sonoma Index Tribune
Sonoma County Property Tax payment deadline nears; pay on time or pay penalty
> Sonoma Valley Patch
Ever thought about serving on the Sonoma County Grand Jury?
> Sonoma County Court
Sonoma County Economic Development Board releases demographic data about Latino community
> Santa Rosa Press Democrat
Weather forecast indicates April showers in store for California.
> National Weather Force
California utilties claim solar panel owners are to blame for rising electricity prices
> Grist
Bureaucratic inertia and Sacramento/ San Joagiun Delta water supply a bad combo
> New York Times
What past CA droughts can tell us, archaeologists deconstruct Medieval Climate Anomaly
> Digital Commons Cal Poly
County drought news better than Central Valley but still the news not good
> Santa Rosa Press Democrat
Bay area population growth continues; Sonoma County close to 1% from 2013 to 2014
Low Sierra snowpack, effects ripple through economy and environment
> Santa Rosa Press Democrat
Long delayed south Napa resort resurrected; large hotel, maybe golf course (or vineyards) 
> Napa Valley Register
Bay Area affordable housing: increasing shortage, increasingly long commutes
Make reservations to tour the Sonoma Valley wastewater treatment plant on April 18th
> Sonoma County Water Agency
Juvenile felony arrest rate in Sonoma County trending downwards
> Kids Data - Lucile Packard Foundation
Wine geeks: Matthew McConaughey is starring in ‘The Billionares Vinegar’ film adaptation
> Eater
More Following Stories...
Live Traffic
Link to Live Crime Map